Thermodynamic Magic Enables Cooling without Energy Consumption

Physicists at UZH have developed a simple device that allows heat to flow temporarily from a cold to a warm object without an external power supply.
If you put a teapot of boiling water on the kitchen table, it will gradually cool down. However, its temperature is not expected to fall below that of the table. It is precisely this everyday experience that illustrates one of the fundamental laws of physics – the second law of thermodynamics – which states that the entropy of a closed natural system must increase over time. Or, more simply put: Heat can flow by itself only from a warmer to a colder object, and not the other way round.
Cooling below room temperature
The results of a recent experiment carried out by the research group of Prof. Andreas Schilling in the Department of Physics at the University of Zurich (UZH) appear at first sight to challenge the second law of thermodynamics. The researchers managed to cool a nine-gram piece of copper from over 100°C to significantly below room temperature without an external power supply. “Theoretically, this experimental device could turn boiling water to ice, without using any energy,” says Schilling.
Creating oscillating heat currents
To achieve this, the researchers used a Peltier element, a component commonly used, for example, to cool minibars in hotel rooms. These elements can transform electric currents into temperature differences. The researchers had already used this type of element in previous experiments, in connection with an electric inductor, to create an oscillating heat current in which the flow of heat between two bodies perpetually changed direction. In this scenario, heat also temporarily flows from a colder to a warmer object so that the colder object is cooled down further. This kind of “thermal oscillating circuit” in effect contains a “thermal inductor”. It functions in the same way as an electrical oscillating circuit, in which the voltage oscillates with a constantly changing sign.
Laws of physics remain intact
Until now, Schilling’s team had only operated these thermal oscillating circuits using an energy source. The researchers have now shown for the first time that this kind of thermal oscillating circuit can also be operated “passively”, i.e. with no external power supply. Thermal oscillations still occurred and, after a while, heat flowed directly from the colder copper to a warmer heat bath with a temperature of 22°C, without being temporarily transformed into another form of energy. Despite this, the authors were also able to show that the process does not actually contradict any laws of physics. To prove it, they considered the change in entropy of the whole system and showed that it increased with time – fully in accordance with the second law of thermodynamics.
Potential application still a long way off
Although the team recorded a difference of only about 2°C compared to the ambient temperature in the experiment, this was mainly due to the performance limitations of the commercial Peltier element used. According to Schilling, it would be possible in theory to achieve cooling of up to -47°C under the same conditions, if the “ideal” Peltier element – yet to be invented – could be used: “With this very simple technology, large amounts of hot solid, liquid or gaseous materials could be cooled to well below room temperature without any energy consumption.”
The passive thermal circuit could also be used as often as desired, without the need to connect it to a power supply. However, Schilling admits that a large-scale application of the technique is still a long way off. One reason for this is that the Peltier elements currently available are not efficient enough. Furthermore, the current set-up requires the use of superconducting inductors to minimize electric losses.
Established perceptions challenged
Schilling considers the work more significant than a mere “proof-of-principle” study: “At first sight, the experiments appear to be a kind of thermodynamic magic, thereby challenging to some extent our traditional perceptions of the flow of heat.”
Further reading
A. Schilling, X. Zhang, and O. Bossen. Heat flowing from cold to hot without external intervention by using a "thermal inductor". Science Advances 5, eaat9953 (2019). DOI: 10.1126/sciadv.aat9953
Contact:
Prof. Dr. Andreas Schilling
Department of Physics
University of Zurich
Phone: +41 44 635 57 91
E-mail: schilling@physik.uzh.ch
More news
- SwissCollNet supports the scientific collections of the UZH on a large scale
- New: Zoological Museum offers guided tours in Ukrainian
- Science and Operations Service team up for a clean Irchelpark
- Cooperation by necessity – female house mice breed communally to improve their chance to reproduce
- Physicist Laura Baudis honored with Charpak Ritz Prize 2022
- Minor Days 2022
- Gravitational waves become tangible
- Successfull Science Info Day 2022
- FDFA International Career Day
- Scientists discover how galaxies can exist without dark matter
- Green Labs Group wins SCNAT UChange Program Grant
- Cyber-Defence Fellowships – A Talent Program for Cyber-Defence Research
- The Mainz Academy of Sciences and Literatures admits Laura Baudis as member
- Particle physicist Florencia Canelli will represent Switzerland on the CERN Council from 2022 onwards
- Ecologist Jordi Bascompte honored with Margalef award 2021
- ETH honors MNF chemist Fabian von Rohr with Ruzicka Prize 2021
- Recruiting and evaluating without bias: MNF launches awareness campaign
- New Master programm: Interdisciplinary Brain Sciences
- New@MNF: Theoretical particle physicist Peter Stoffer
- From Epicurus, Bioinspired Machine Learning and Happiness - Visiting Professor Eleni Vasilaki
- #New@MNF - Prof. Tina Perica
- Corinna Ulcigrai: Invited Speaker at the ICM 2022
- Covid certificate required for freshers day
- Covid Certificates Required for On-Site Classes
- UZI 5: New research building on the Irchel campus inaugurated
- DQBM Founding Symposium
- Sandra Luber honored with Coblentz Award 2021
- Cyber-Defence Fellowships – A Talent Program for Cyber-Defence Research
- Coming soon: Test flights for biodiversiy research
- Science and Nature Festival on Campus Irchel: May 22 to May 30
- Simran Tinan: First UZH PhD student to receive a CYD Fellowship.
- How does the environment impact our wellbeing?
- Theoretical Physicist Thomas Gehrmann honored with ERC Advanced Grant
- Meerkats from Campus Irchel as TV stars
- Earth System Science: Permafrost is thawing globally
- Minor Days 2021
- New Results Challenge Leading Theory in Physics
- Scientific Programming with Python 2021
- Cristina Nevado choosen for the "Dr. Margaret Faul Women in Chemistry Award 2021"
- The Python code WannierBerri developed by Stepan Tsirkin breaks the records of speed in evaluation of anomalous transport in solids.
- Go-ahead for SKA - the biggest radiotelescope on Earth
- Machine Learning kompakt: New e-book gives a compact introduction into machine learning.
- Sustainability Committee Grant: Make Irchel more sustainable
- GERDA final results: Another milestone in the search for neutrinoless double-beta decay
- Astrophysics: How nearby galaxies form their stars
- Kai Niebert appointed as member of the German Bioeconomy Council
- Undergraduate Project "Plant Immunity Based Biosensing" recognized as Best Undergrad New Application Project
- At the Limits of What’s Possible
- Highly cited researchers: Clarivate publishes 2020 list of most influential researchers
- Ariel moves from blueprint to reality
- How giant planets turn gas to metal
- Bernhard Schmid was elected this year's Eminent Ecologist by the Journal of Ecology. At the same time the Ecological Society of Germany, Austria and Switzerland GfÖ awarded him the honorary medal.
- Christian Berndt has been awarded an honorary professorship at University of Nottingham
- The student garden at UZH is really up and running
- Rüdiger Wehner has been awarded Fellow of the Royal Institute of Navigation, London
- Drone flights between USZ and Campus Irchel
- Stefan Sauter has been elected as Member of the European Academy of Sciences
- Starting next Fall Semester: Minor Study Program in BioMed Entrepreneurship
- Observation of Excess Events in the XENON1T Dark Matter Experiment
- Ancient Andes Analyzed: Genomic Portrait of Pre-Columbian Andean Civilizations
- COVID-19: Basic Safety Concept and Fact Sheet on conduct on UZH premises Faculty of Science (MNF)
- Hanna Kokko new member of American Academy of Arts and Sciences
- Faculty of Science awards the title of honorary doctor to Jane Goodall
- ABCD: How to make scientific conferences more sustainable and divers
- Mathematician Corinna Ulcigrai honored with Brin Prize
- Karl Gademann honored as Chemistry Europe Fellow
- Information on the corona virus
- Science Info Day: UZH's Study Progams in Natural Sciences and Mathematics
- Mathematician Camillo De Lellis honored with Bôcher Memorial Prize 2020
- Physicist Titus Neupert honored with Klung-Wilhemy Award
- Rapid evolutionary change in a grassland biodiversity experiment
- Closing in on elusive particles
- Astrophysicist Lucio Mayer elected as board member of the MERAC Foundation
- UZH Entrepreneur Fellowships in BioTech & MedTech
- Büroccoli and Strebergärtli – student’s garden projects @UZH Science Campus Irchel
- Irchel Nature Trail has opened
- Mathematician Artur Avila elected as Member by NAS
- Chemist Cristina Nevado receives Organometallic Chemistry Award by Royal Society of Chemistry
- Biochemist Ben Schuler receives HFSP Research Grant
- Mathematician Xavier Ros-Oton honored with Spanish Scientific Research Award
- Award 3.0 : Theoretical Chemist Luber receives Open Eye Outstanding Junior Faculty Award
- Another Award for Sandra Luber
- ERC-Research Funds for Physicist Gino Isidori and Mathematician Benjamin Schlein
- Irchel Nature Trail - Grand Opening on 22 May 2019
- American Physical Society Honors Titus Neupert as Outstanding Referee for 2019
- Theoretical Chemist Sandra Luber honored with Block Prize
- Science Info Day 2019: Information Event for Future Students
- March 14th, 2019. Y 15 G 19 Irchel, 17:00
- MNF-Professor Kentaro Shimizu one of the 50 Japanese who move the world
- Honoris causa: Universidad del Norte appoints Mathematician Joachim Rosenthal as Honorary Professor
- FameLab 2019: Get ready for the challenge
- Nuclearia is protist of the year 2019 declares DGP
- Sandra Luber honored with Carl-Duisberg-Gedächtnispreis
- Chris Marentini honored with Dectris-Award for best Master Thesis in experimental physics
- Michael Baudis elected to GA4GH steering committee and as chair of Bioinformatics and Data Analytics group of SPHN
- Miescher Award 2019 goes to Bernd Bodenmiller
- Bascompte, Bolch, Martinoia, van der Heijden, von Mering and Zipfel are Highly Cited Researchers 2018
- ERC Synergy Grant for biochemists Andreas Plückthun and Ohad Medalia
- ERC Consolidator Grants 2018: Melanie Greter and Martin Jinek receive prestigious grants
- Flows of carbon between ecosystems underestimated
- Genesis 2.0 - discussing the movie
- 27.11.2018: Welcome event Gruezi@UZH for Science and Medicine
- Formation of mysterious structures within the Antarctic and Greenlandic Ice Sheet explained
- Biodiversity: Does the dispersion of species always follow the same rules?
- Zukunftstag for #Kids: Some openings are still available
- Café Scientifique: Davide Scaramuzza on "Autonomous, Agile, Vision-controlled drones"
- Greta Patzke appointed scientific counselor of AEE Suisse.
- From first cells to first heartbeat: visualizing heart development
- Call for UZH Entrepreneur-Fellowship BioTech and MedTech
- Florian Altermatt appointed Associate Professor for Aquatic Ecology
- Slow or fast? Soil moisture as a critical limitation of vegetation development in a warming tundra.
- Morning gene activity in the field but not in the laboratories
- No evidence of 'hobbit' ancestry in genomes of Flores Island pygmies
- Fields Medal Winner Artur Avila Appointed Full Professor at UZH
- #NewProfessor: Francesca Peri - master of thousands of zebrafish
- Resurrecting Darwin’s Bulldog-Faced Argentinian Cow
- Novel Insulators with Conducting Edges
- Higgs boson reaches the top
- The Nagoya Protocol — a possible obstacle to research cooperation
- XENON1T probes deeper into Dark Matter WIMPs, with 1300 kg of cold Xe atoms
- Cyril Zipfel honored with the Tsuneko & Reiji Okazaki Award
- Cyril Zipfel elected as EMBO member
- Werner Prize 2018 awarded to Sandra Luber
- MNF-PhD Student awarded with British Ecological Society's Southwood Prize
- UZH Days of the laboratory animals: 20. und 23. April
- Minor Days 2018: Die Nebenfachangebote der MNF
- New Method Speeds Up Development of Medication
- Make Irchel Greener - submit your ideas
- Call for PSC Summer School: Responsible Research and Innovation in Plant Sciences
- From the laboratory to bedside
- LISA mission passes review successfully and begins next stage of development
- Jason Holland receives Grant by Schweizer Krebsliga
- Science Alumni launch mentoring-progamm for MNF-students
- 2017: Our successfull students
- Sara Fabrikant and former PhD Student Marco Salvini win Breheny Prize
- Sandra Luber wins Robin Hochstrasser Young Investigator Award
- Peter Hamm elected as Fellow Member by OSA
- Magdalini Polymenidou becomes EMBO Young Investigator
- Gender Equality Event: Where are all the women?
- Welcome event Grüezi@UZH for Medicine and Science
- Lecture "Lehrperson 2020: Human Error oder Win-Win?"
- Exhibition: André Dreiding and his Molecular Models
- Nationaler Zukunftstag: Kids on Compus Irchel
- SNSF-Professor Sandra Luber honored with Hellmann-Award
- Sandra Luber and the modelling of future energy supply
- The good, the bad and their equilibrium: New insight in protein aggregation in neurons and new possible pathways for medical treatment
- Kosmische Teilchen: Lesen von unsichtbaren Schriften
- Talk: Gender Equality in Universities - the problems and solutions
- Florian Altermatt appointed Vice-President of Biodiversity Forum
- Counting women: The challenges of being a female mathematician
- Minor Days 2017: Die Nebenfachprogramme der MNF
- LHCb adds a new piece to developing puzzle in particle physics.
- European Girl's Mathematical Olympiad 2017
- Plant Science Center Summer School: Call for Registration
- Show me Science! Call for Participation für die ScienceComm'17
- Zurich-Basel Plant Science Center Symposium: "Public Engagement with Science - Relevance and Methods"
- Ice Age identified as one of the main killing mechanism for the biggest mass extinction
- Ready to challenge the frontiers of Particle Physics
- Beat Keller was honored with the IWGSC Award
- First glimpse on a single protein - the original idea of holography is now reality
- Imaging spectroscopy Article Makes it to the Cover of Methods in Ecology and Evolution
- Jason Holland appointed to two editorial boards
- 3D vision for machines
- Eri Yamasaki honored with Suzuki Award
- Department of Geography to become global center for biodiversity research
- Karl Gademann elected as member of SNSF's National Research Council
- Ecologist Jordi Bascompte honored with BES Marsh Book Award 2016
- 5 MNF-researchers among world’s most influential scientific minds.
- Assistant professor Madhavi Krishnan receives ERC Consolidator Grant
- Assistant professor Giacomo Indiveri receives ERC Consolidator Grant
- Republic of Sacha honors ecologist Dr. Gabriela Schaepman-Strub
- Swiss Bridge Foundation awards Dr. Alexa Burger and Prof. Christian Mosimann with 250'000 Swiss Franks
- Opening of the Student's Bar on Campus Irchel
- Women in Science: An evening of inspiration and advice on building a successful career in science
- Grüezi@Irchel
- Climate change and the capital market
- LS 2 Annual Meeting 2017
- Zukunftstag 2017: Kinder an den Campus Irchel
- 29. Oktober 2016: 10. Obstsortenmarkt im Botanischen Garten
- Podiumsdiskussion mit Klimaforscherin Gabriela Schaepman-Strub
- Public Talk: How universities can move societies to address sustainability - individual actions an global movements
- Public Lecture with Prof. Lawrence Krauss on Gravitational Waves and Turning Metaphysics into Physics
- Information Lunch: Personalized Health Alliance - Zurich Cluster
- Mathematician Laure Saint-Raymond joins Faculty as Hedi Fritz Niggli visiting professor
- Shanghai Ranking: UZH on position 54
- 3. September: Die lange Nacht der Zürcher Museen
- Prof. Kai Niebert met and discussed with Chancellor Angela Merkel
- #New Professor: Astrophysicist Ravit Helled joins Computational Science
- CERN and the Large Hadron Collider - News from the Energy Frontier
- Devis Tuia wins U.V. Helava award 2012 - 2015
- #NewProfessor @MNF: Titus Neupert
- Ein Wassertropfen als Modell für das Wechselspiel von Haftreibung und Adhäsion
- Felix Zelder gewinnt Auszeichnung der Royal Society of Chemistry
- Bundesrat zeichnet Geographin Karin Schwiter aus
- Promising treatment prospects for invasive breast cancer
- Vision 2020 - A Personal Perspective: Genetic Testing
- Denksport mit Prof. Anna Beliakova
- #NewProfessor @MNF: Jason Holland
- SummärBar auf dem Irchel: 17. Mai bis 2. Juni
- #New Professor @MNF: Marcello Porta
- High-performance microscope displays pores in the cell nucleus with greater precision
- International Physics Olympiad 2016